Fatigue Failure

Stebin
Samuel

In the engineering world, most cases of material failure occur as a result of fatigue. Fatigue failure is the fracture that occurs in a material as a result of prolonged loads. In this article, you will learn what fatigue failure is, real world examples of fatigue failure, and tools to mitigate fatigue failure.

Reliability Prediction for Components in Fatigue - ReliaSoft
Courtesy: Reliasoft

What is Fatigue Failure?

Fatigue failure deals with the material of an object and the associated material science. It occurs when a material is put under cyclic stress that is below its yield strength and the material fails. Yield strength refers to the point on an engineering stress strain curve where a material fails. Failure is the crack, fracture, or tear propagation in the material that causes fracture in the material.

Stress Strain Relationship

Once a material deforms plastically, it cannot go back to its original form. Plastic deformation occurs right before the fracture of a material and is a result of prolonged fatigue. As a material deforms plastically, microscopic cracks propagate and connect causing failure in the material. The time to failure depends on the load, intensity, and type of stress on the material. It is important to understand the way that cracks propagate as failure may be catastrophic to any types of industrial application. Because of this, better design against crack propagation requires understanding of fatigue failure. It is important to test a material to identify its endurance limit before considering it as a building material.

Stress–strain curve - Wikipedia
Courtesy: Wiki

At the microscopic level, the cyclic stress on a material propagates microscopic cracks which connect as the stress continues. Typically, the cracks propagate at sharper corners, knobs, and other harder to see areas. Because of this, lot of cracks that propagate in real world applications are often very hard to see. An example of fatigue based failure is the repeated cyclic load on a crankshaft in a car engine. Because of the cyclic nature of combustion engines, shear stress may cause fatigue failure which would be catastrophic in the operation of a car. Because of this, many design considerations have been made to prevent failure in the modern designs of crank shafts.

S-N Curve

Fatigue strength and life are two parameters that also help to quantify the fatigue limit of a material. An S-N curve outlines the relationship between stress and the number of cycles to failure which in turn show whether or not a material has a fatigue limit in which it fails, or a fatigue strength, at which it deforms.

Fatigue Limit Curve
Courtesy: Inspectioneering
No Fatigue Limit Curve
Courtesy: Inspectioneering

Stages of Fatigue Failure

Stages in fatigue failure of the sample showing crack initiation site,... |  Download Scientific Diagram
Courtesy: ResearchGate

Initiation

Fatigue failure follows three major steps to failure. The first step is the initiation process. Initiation is when irreversible, plastic changes occur in the material. The origination of the initiation is microscopic and failure never occurs too far from it. The initiation phase is the most studied as preventing initiation altogether helps remove the possibility of failure out of design.

Propagation

Propagation is the second step in fatigue failure and is when the microscopic cracks begin to grow. This stage of fatigue failure is when failure may most easily be identified. The physically aspects of the crack begin to express themselves as the material is in its early stages of failure.

Failure

The final stage of fatigue failure if the rupture of the growing cracks. Once all the microscopic cracks have expressed themselves and connected, the material breaks. The fracture occurs in many different ways depending on the type of stress and load the material is put under.

What's wrong with my precast concrete garage? - Page 2 of 4 - Construction  Specifier
Courtesy: Construction Specifier

Types of Fatigue Failure and Examples

There are two main types of fatigue failures: mechanical fatigue and thermal fatigue.

Mechanical Fatigue Factors

Mechanical fatigue identifies sources of fatigue that develop as a result of physical stresses on a mechanism. This may be from any type of action that occurs on a component.

Vibration Fatigue

Vibration fatigue is a form of mechanical fatigue and is induced by vibration. It typically occurs when loading a component outside its intended design. Similarly, vibration fatigue may also occur as a result of improper damping. If held too stiff, cyclic vibrations will cause crack propagation in a material such as a shaft. A real world example of vibration fatigue is the vibration at a nozzle on a pressure vessel. As the nozzle on a system experiences fluctuating fluid pressure, the stress may cause for cracking in the welds used to hold them in place. As a result, the nozzle welds may fail and cause catastrophic damage to a system.

Vibration induce cracking 1.png
Courtesy: Amarineblog

Corrosion Fatigue

Corrosion fatigue is another form of mechanical failure and occurs as a result of corrosive elements on a material. Once a material becomes corroded, it weakens from its initial state making it susceptible to crack development and propagation. Coating against any corrosive substances when designing is an important part of preventing against this type of fatigue failure. A real world example of corrosion fatigue is the De Havilland plane crashes of 1954. The plane fuselage was uncoated and lead to crack mitigation deep within the material. After continuous flights and cyclic stress to the fuselage, the crack grew and the material failed causing catastrophic failure of the plane.

Courtesy: Materials.unsw

Thermal Fatigue

Thermal fatigue is a type of fatigue that occurs as a result of thermal stresses on a material. Prolonged temperature changes in a material not designed for such applications may cause for catastrophic failure in some cases. A real world example of thermal fatigue is brake rotor cracking. Car brakes under go cyclic loading and intense thermal fatigue as they are used on and off on a car. Brake rotors may become extremely thin and crack as a result of thermal fatigue in combination with the physical stress it undergoes.

Thermal fatigue cracks on a disc brake.11 | Download Scientific Diagram
Courtesy: ResearchGate

Tools to Mitigate Fatigue Failure

With modern technology, identifying weak point susceptible to fatigue in many applications has become a viable way to prevent failure. For modes of failure such as corrosion fatigue, chemical coatings are good modern solutions to weaknesses in deisgn. However, for more physical modes of failure, such as vibration fatigue, modeling the design becomes important to know how to design against failure.

FEA or finite element analsysis softwares are computerized tools that may accuratley model how physical and thermal forces may affect a design. FEA tools from AUTOdesk and Solidworks allow users to input their design and materials to model the conditions the assembly experiences. The software models the identified factors and identifies any weak points in the design where failure may occur.

Getting Started with SOLIDWORKS Simulation - Introduction to Finite Element Analysis
Courtesy: Solidworks